No, she doesn't. She opposes health benefits for gay and lesbian partners, and supported a $1.2 million non-binding advisory vote for legislation that would have taken away the partner benefits granted by an Alaska Supreme Court ruling. (The vote passed by a narrow margin, and the benefits remain.)
For the full story on the health benefits, see: Alaskans Together on Palin's LGBT Record. For Palin on other gay issues, see the Sarah Palin Series.
But conflicting reports about Gov. Sarah Palin's stand on gay rights are showing up all over the web. Outside reporters know little about her record on gay rights (or anything else) and call her everything from ally to enemy.
The mainstream media says she opposes same-sex marriage but has gay friends and is sympathetic to gay issues. (Their evidence of her sympathy shows how little they know about her.)
The national liberal and conservative media found something to agree on: that Palin is anti-gay.
The evangelical writers are excited to vote for her, the progressives are disgusted by her anti-health benefits stand and by the media's "gay friends" spin.
The national LGBT media recognizes her opposition to equality and civil rights - except the Log Cabin Republicans (gay republicans, believe it or not) who think she is a wonderful choice.
And the fringe elements are joining the fray.
In these reports, I found only two LGBT Alaskans quoted (both in the same article by Gay City News):
Some press reports following the McCain campaign announcement have repeated the right-wing rhetorical flourish that has Palin declaring that she has gay friends. That softer image is not what some Alaskans saw."That's just completely wrong," said Allison E. Mendel, the attorney who brought the 1999 [partner benefits] case. "She spoke on radio programs all throughout the campaign saying, 'I want a constitutional amendment, I think these things are only for a man and a woman.' ... I don't think she's ever said a friendly word about gay people, that they ought to have health benefits like other people do or anything along those lines."On AIDS issues, Palin simply has no record at all."There is not a lot to speak of for AIDS policy because she hasn't done much," said Trevor Storrs, executive director of the Alaskan AIDS Assistance Association. "She's never been given the opportunity to address our situation here because it has never been put before her.""She has done very little to address the major epidemics," he said.
But the most often quoted sentence about her stand on gay rights was from her old Wiki profile: "She opposes same-sex marriage, but she has stated that she has gay friends and is receptive to gay and lesbian concerns about discrimination."
Then her Wiki profile was changed and currently reads: "Palin has said she has good friends who are gay, opposes same-sex marriage, but complied with an Alaskan state Supreme Court order and signed an implementation of same-sex benefits into law, stating that legal options to avoid doing so had run out. She supported a non-binding referendum for a constitutional amendment to deny benefits to homosexual couples."
The Associated Press reported that Palin "opposes gay marriage -- constitutionally banned in Alaska before her time -- but exercised a veto that essentially granted benefits to gay state employees and their partners."
That sentence is quoted in numerous articles to imply that she is sympathetic to gay and lesbian rights.
The national LGBT rights group HRC has the real story:
"Sarah Palin not only supported the 1998 Alaska constitutional amendment banning marriage equality but, in her less than two years as Governor, even expressed the extreme position of supporting stripping away domestic partner benefits for state workers. When you can't even support giving our community the rights to health insurance and pension benefits, it's a frightening window into where she stands on equality."
Meanwhile, someone has created a web site called Sarah Palin Gay Rights . com. This is the full text:
Sarah Palin (GOV-Alaska-Republican), supports gay rights, says Anchorage Daily News.Quote "Gov. Sarah Palin vetoed a bill Thursday that sought to block the state from giving public employee benefits such as health insurance to same-sex couples."Quote ""It is the Governor's intention to work with the legislature and to give the people of Alaska an opportunity to express their wishes and intentions whether these benefits should continue," the statement from Palin's administration said."Coghill said he's interested in a new plan that would allow state employees to designate one person -- maybe a same-sex partner, but also possibly a family member or roommate -- who would be eligible for state-paid benefits. But the employee would have to pay to add that person to his or her benefits."Sarah Palin's veto gave gays the same rights as married couples in Alaska.A vote for McCain/Palin is a vote for gay marriage.
The quotes don't support the conclusion, but the overall message is clear: evangelicals should not be fooled into voting for McCain because they think Palin supports their agenda. The site is anonymous, maybe by a disgruntled Huckabee supporter?
Many readers of Bent Alaska are LGBT Alaskans and our allies. You know more about Sarah and gay rights in Alaska than the Outsiders. What do you think about Palin and gay rights?
Respectfully I wish to expose the method which HRC operates. HRC press releases such as the one found on your post which would lead you to beleave that their efforts are strictly on behalf of gays and lesbian people......."Sarah Palin not only supported the 1998 Alaska constitutional amendment banning marriage equality but, in her less than two years as Governor, even expressed the extreme position of supporting stripping away domestic partner benefits for state workers. When you can't even support giving our community the rights to health insurance and pension benefits, it's a frightening window into where she stands on equality."
ReplyDeleteWhat HRC SAYS and DOES are TWO different things.
In a statement regarding the McCain vice presidential nomination Log Cabin President Patrick Sammon stated "Gov. Palin is an inclusive Republican who will help Sen. McCain appeal to gay and lesbian voters.”
planetransgender "HRC and Log Cabin Republican political choices"
http://tinyurl.com/5uu83z
Steve Driscoll, Co-Chair of the Stonewall Democrats dicusses his feelings about the Log Cabin Republicans receiving $10,000dollars to sponsor the their DNC efforts from HRC and the Stonewall receiving nothing...."HRC Sucks"....
..."I, for one, will not attend their concert - and I will not go quietly into that good night either".
"Follow The Money" at Boycott HRC
http://tinyurl.com/5k2ma3
I am just pointing to the glaring fact. HRC lies to the poor and caters to the rich.
We transgender have suffered long and mightly at the expert hands of HRC. Maybe it's time for HRC to pay the piper.
I understand your concerns about HRC. But what do you think about Gov. Palin and LGBT issues?
ReplyDeleteI want to state first, I am not an Alaskan, and am not gay. I am a supporter of lgbt equal rights, including marriage.
ReplyDeleteI think I have read, the course of the last week, about everything there is to read on this topic. Sigh.
Here is the rundown. You can go to my site and look for this section in a post called "The GOP Strategy on Palin: The "Alaska Maverick". It is a post on many of her positions. Go to the fifth red topic. You can pick up the live links there.
I apologize for the length.
Maverick on civil rights for lgbt folks? No.
Palin supported (right up to 2007) marriage as defined by one man/one woman.
Here is a history, with links because this subject is a bit convoluted and tricky.
_______________Cut and USE_______________
1. "Palin said she's not out to judge anyone and has good friends who are gay, but that she supported the 1998 constitutional amendment." [this bill defined marriage as man/woman] From this.
2. The language of Ballot Measure 2 (1998) can be read here.
So, Palin SAID in the article that she voted for one man/one woman definition of marriage. THERE it is.
3. 9 lgbt couples sued over Measure 2 in 1999. In 2005, the court returned an "unconstitutional" decision on the 1998 constitutional amendment banning gay marriage (actually, it affirms opposite sex marriage, but same result).
4. Then the issue got even more openly sticky and hostile.
In response to the 2005 court decision to the 1998 amendment (Measure 2), the Alaska legislature passed HB4001 and HB4002. Text of HB 4001 is here.
5. This is the Governor's press release on her veto of HB 4001 from 2006.
6. Now, as for HB 4002, Palin signed this on Dec. 20, 2006. The bill put before the voters an ADVISORY vote on benefits for same sex partners of employees and retirees. The point of HB 4002, in Palin's own words: "Palin has said that when voters approved a constitutional amendment defining marriage as the union of a man and a woman eight years ago, many believed they were also implying that a gay partner shouldn't get state benefits." This comment is located about half way through this article.
7. Here is the language of HB 4002 as sent to the governor.
8. Here is the governor's office release on HR 4002, and NOTE the language in it about the 1998 amendment. [interestingly, look at the DATE on this--8/29/08. This must have been put up in response to press questions? Odd. I almost have to wonder if it is original, but it does come from her office.]
9. HR 4002 mandated a vote to capture opinion on the benefits issue on April 3, 2007. The results of the Advisory referendum, held as a special election on April 3, 2007 , costing $1.2million, are here. The referendum passed (meaning, a yes vote was to limit benefits, a no vote would extend benefits to partners of same gender employees and retirees).
<______________________________>
I am still looking for the actual ballot language for Measure 2. Will post when located.
Best to you.
There are several additional points in the post from Alaskans Together, including Gov. Palin's response to a 3rd piece of LGBT legislation. Read "Alaskans Together on Palin's LGBT Record" for the full story.
ReplyDeleteI'm adding new posts almost daily on Sarah Palin and LGBT rights, so keep checking back.
Thanks for supporting LGBT rights!
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete